Blog Details

Supreme Court of Bangladesh -2027 Appellate Division vs High Court Division

The Supreme Court of Bangladesh is the highest court in the country. Under Article 94(1) of the Constitution, the Supreme Court consists of two separate divisions: the Appellate Division and the High Court Division. Although both are parts of the same Supreme Court, their jurisdictions and functions are different. BD Laws

1. The Supreme Court of Bangladesh

The Constitution establishes the Supreme Court as the apex judicial institution of Bangladesh. Article 94 provides for the two divisions and also establishes the independence of the Chief Justice and other judges in exercising their judicial functions. BD Laws

The structure can be simplified as:

SUPREME COURT OF BANGLADESH

→ Appellate Division

→ High Court Division

The two divisions are not two separate courts. They are two divisions of the same Supreme Court, with distinct constitutional and statutory jurisdictions.

2. Appellate Division

The Appellate Division is the highest appellate forum in Bangladesh.

Its principal function is to hear appeals from judgments, decrees, orders and sentences of the High Court Division under Article 103 of the Constitution. BD Laws

Main functions of the Appellate Division

The Appellate Division has several important jurisdictions.

A. Appellate jurisdiction

The Appellate Division hears appeals from the High Court Division.

An appeal lies as of right in constitutionally specified circumstances, including where the High Court Division:

• certifies that the case involves a substantial question of law concerning interpretation of the Constitution;
• confirms a death sentence or sentences a person to death or imprisonment for life; or
• imposes punishment for contempt of the High Court Division.

In other cases covered by Article 103(3), an appeal requires leave to appeal from the Appellate Division. Parliament may also provide additional appellate routes by legislation. BD Laws

B. Power to do complete justice

Article 104 gives the Appellate Division broad power to issue directions, orders, decrees or writs necessary for doing complete justice in a matter pending before it. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

This power can include orders concerning the attendance of persons and discovery or production of documents.

C. Review jurisdiction

Under Article 105, the Appellate Division can review its own judgments or orders, subject to the Constitution, applicable legislation and its rules. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

D. Advisory jurisdiction

The Appellate Division also has a constitutional advisory function under Article 106.

Where the President considers that a question of law has arisen or is likely to arise and that the question is of such a nature and public importance that obtaining the Supreme Court's opinion is expedient, the President may refer the question to the Appellate Division.

The Division may then provide its opinion after such hearing as it considers appropriate. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

3. High Court Division

The High Court Division (HCD) has a much broader range of jurisdiction.

Article 101 provides that the High Court Division has the original, appellate and other jurisdictions, powers and functions conferred upon it by the Constitution or other laws. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Unlike the Appellate Division, the High Court Division is not limited primarily to hearing appeals. It can hear certain matters at first instance, hear appeals and revisions from subordinate courts and exercise important constitutional powers.

4. Original Jurisdiction of the High Court Division

Original jurisdiction means that the High Court Division can hear certain matters as a court of first instance rather than as an appellate court.

One of its most important original jurisdictions arises under Article 102 of the Constitution.

Writ jurisdiction

Under Article 102, the High Court Division can exercise constitutional jurisdiction in appropriate cases, including enforcement of fundamental rights and judicial review of actions or failures of public authorities. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

For example, a person may approach the High Court Division where a public authority has allegedly acted beyond its lawful authority or where constitutional rights require enforcement.

The High Court Division also has original jurisdiction in certain matters under legislation, including specified company, admiralty and other statutory matters. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

5. Appellate Jurisdiction of the High Court Division

The High Court Division also hears appeals from subordinate courts and other forums where legislation gives it appellate jurisdiction.

For example, the Supreme Court identifies appellate jurisdiction arising under legislation including the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, as well as certain specialised statutes. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Therefore, a case does not necessarily begin in the Supreme Court.

A typical litigation pathway may be:

Subordinate Court → High Court Division → Appellate Division

But this is a simplified pathway. The actual route depends on the particular law and type of case.

6. Revisional Jurisdiction

The High Court Division also exercises revisional jurisdiction in appropriate cases.

For civil matters, section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides a statutory basis for revision in specified circumstances.

For criminal matters, section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides revisional jurisdiction, subject to the statutory requirements.

The High Court Division also has inherent criminal jurisdiction under section 561A of the CrPC in circumstances recognised by law. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Revision should not simply be understood as another ordinary appeal. Its scope and grounds are governed by the relevant legislation.

7. Superintendence Over Subordinate Courts

Another major distinction is the High Court Division's constitutional role in relation to subordinate courts.

Article 109 provides that:

The High Court Division has superintendence and control over all courts and tribunals subordinate to it.

This gives the High Court Division an important supervisory role over the subordinate judiciary. BD Laws

The High Court Division can also withdraw certain cases from subordinate courts under Article 110 where the constitutional conditions specified in that provision are satisfied. BD Laws

8. Appellate Division vs High Court Division

The Supreme Court itself explains that the two divisions have separate jurisdictions, derived from the Constitution as well as Acts of Parliament. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

9. Which Division Is Higher?

Within the Supreme Court structure, the Appellate Division is the final appellate authority, while the High Court Division is the lower of the two divisions.

This relationship is particularly important because Article 111 of the Constitution provides that the law declared by the Appellate Division is binding on the High Court Division, while the law declared by either division is binding on subordinate courts. BD Laws

Therefore:

Appellate Division

↓ Binding law

High Court Division

↓ Binding law

Subordinate Courts

This principle helps maintain consistency in the interpretation and application of law throughout the judicial system.

10. A Simple Example

Suppose a person loses a case before a subordinate court.

If the applicable law provides an appeal to the High Court Division, the person may challenge the decision there.

The pathway may therefore be:

Subordinate Court

↓

High Court Division

↓

Appellate Division

However, the right to appeal is not automatic in every case. The relevant legislation determines whether an appeal exists and what requirements must be satisfied.

For an appeal from the High Court Division to the Appellate Division, Article 103 determines when an appeal lies as of right and when leave to appeal is required. BD Laws

11. Why the Difference Matters

The distinction between the two divisions is important because they perform fundamentally different judicial functions.

The High Court Division is particularly important for:

constitutional review, writ petitions, appeals, revisions, supervision of subordinate courts and specified original matters.

The Appellate Division is particularly important for:

final appeals, authoritative interpretation of law, review of its own judgments, complete-justice orders and constitutional advisory opinions.

Thus, the High Court Division is not simply a "lower court" in the ordinary sense. It performs major constitutional and supervisory functions in addition to hearing appeals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the High Court Division part of the Supreme Court?

Yes. The Constitution expressly provides that the Supreme Court of Bangladesh consists of the High Court Division and Appellate Division. BD Laws

Is the Appellate Division higher than the High Court Division?

Yes. The Appellate Division is the country's highest appellate forum, and Article 111 makes the law declared by it binding on the High Court Division. BD Laws

Can a case start in the High Court Division?

Yes. The High Court Division has original jurisdiction in certain matters, including constitutional proceedings under Article 102 and specified statutory matters. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Can every High Court judgment be appealed to the Appellate Division?

No. The Constitution and relevant legislation determine when an appeal lies as of right and when leave to appeal is required. BD Laws

Does the High Court Division hear criminal cases?

Yes. Its jurisdiction includes appellate and revisional criminal jurisdiction under applicable law, in addition to its other constitutional and statutory functions. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Conclusion

The Supreme Court of Bangladesh has two divisions—the High Court Division and the Appellate Division—but they serve different purposes within the judicial system.

The High Court Division has broad original, appellate, revisional and constitutional jurisdiction and exercises superintendence over subordinate courts. The Appellate Division serves as the highest appellate forum, hears appeals from the High Court Division within its constitutional and statutory jurisdiction, can review its own decisions and has an advisory jurisdiction under Article 106. Supreme Court of Bangladesh

Understanding this distinction is essential for anyone trying to understand how litigation, constitutional challenges and appeals move through the courts of Bangladesh.